The Case-Jennings House is a beautiful Shelter Island gem. "Anna's Cottage" was built in 1847 and stands proudly as one of the island's oldest homes.
In the same family for four generations, this two-bedroom treasure was newly renovated and restored in 2017. It is dressed in contemporary farmhouse decor and located within one mile of restaurants, shops, the beach, ferry and a golf course. This immaculate and comfortable space is ready to welcome you to the simpler way of Shelter Island life.
Beach permits are required for access to the town beaches and are available for purchase at the Shelter Island Town Hall. (We do provide the beach towels, chairs (with carrying straps) and an umbrella…
Arriving by bus or train: Go-Fors Taxi & Errand Service
Telephone Number: (PHONE NUMBER HIDDEN)
Owners: John & Anu Kassik